Here's the short answer: since Opening Day 2023, MLB requires all four infielders to stay on the infield dirt, with at least two on each side of second base, and they cannot switch sides during a play. The old full shift — three infielders stacked on one side of second — is gone. The biggest measurable winners have been left-handed hitters, who faced shifts on 62% of their plate appearances in 2022 compared to 22% for righties. I'll walk through what changed, why, and what the data shows about players like Corey Seager and Kyle Schwarber.

Understanding the Traditional Defensive Shift

Before the rule change, the infield shift was a simple, logical tactic: instead of placing defenders in traditional positions, teams moved them to the side of the field where a specific batter was most likely to hit the ball. Dan Chruscinski, writing at The Batters Den, explains that the strategy was fueled by analytics — teams used "spray charts," detailed maps showing where every ball a batter hit landed, to play the odds.

The most common form was the full infield shift: three infielders, or more, positioned on the same side of second base. MLB's own Statcast glossary defines it exactly that way. If a pull-happy left-handed slugger routinely grounded out to the right side, teams simply parked their shortstop and second baseman in shallow right field and let physics do the rest.

This wasn't a fringe tactic by the end. In 2022, the final season it was allowed, MLB teams deployed an infield shift on 38% of all plate appearances league-wide. Left-handed hitters bore the brunt, facing an infield shift on 62% of their plate appearances, according to MLB's shift data. Right-handed hitters saw it just 22% of the time. The shift had become the default defense against an entire class of hitters.

The 2023 MLB Rule Changes: New Infield Positioning Requirements

In September 2022, Major League Baseball announced three rule changes approved by the league's Competition Committee, adopted after extensive testing at the Minor League level over several years and with feedback from MLB player and umpire representatives. The shift limits took effect beginning with the 2023 season.

The positioning requirements are specific. The four infielders must be within the boundary of the infield when the pitcher is on the rubber, and infielders may not switch sides — no repositioning your best defender to the side where the batter is most likely to hit the ball mid-at-bat. Per MLB's glossary, defensive teams must have a minimum of four players on the infield, with at least two infielders completely on either side of second base. ESPN's reporting on the Competition Committee vote adds that both feet must be on the dirt.

There are boundaries to the ban, though. The rule does not preclude a team from positioning an outfielder in the infield or in shallow outfield grass in certain situations, according to MLB. What it does prohibit outright is the four-outfielder alignment. So creativity survives — it's just confined to the dirt, with two fielders committed to each side of second base.

MLB Defensive Shift Rules: Before and After 2023

Here is the full comparison in one place: what teams could do before, what they must do now, and what it has meant for hitters. Note that the player BABIP figures compare 2022 (with shifts) to 2024 (without), per the Berkeley analysis.

MLB infield shift rules and impact: pre-2023 vs. post-2023
Rule AspectPre-2023 (Traditional Shift)Post-2023 (New Rules)Impact / Rationale
Infielder positioningThree or more infielders could stack on one side of second base, leaving the other side open.All four infielders must be on the infield dirt, with at least two completely on each side of second base when the pitcher is on the rubber.Approved September 2022 after years of minor-league testing; aims to give hitters a more balanced defense.
Switching sidesInfielders could freely move based on the batter.Infielders may not switch sides of second base during a play.Prevents extreme alignments where an infielder plays in shallow outfield territory.
Four-outfielder alignmentsPossible in principle.Prohibited, though an outfielder may be positioned in the infield or shallow grass in certain situations.Preserves some tactical flexibility within the dirt-boundary constraint.
Shift frequency (2022)38% of all plate appearances; 62% vs. left-handed hitters, 22% vs. right-handed hitters.Full infield shifts no longer permitted.Left-handed pull hitters were the shift's primary targets.
Left-handed hitter BABIPFrequently suppressed by shifted defenses.All five most-shifted left-handed batters profiled saw BABIP increases from 2022 to 2024.More balls in play are finding holes in the less-shifted infield.
Corey SeagerBABIP of .242 in 2022.BABIP of .291 in 2024 — a nearly 20% increase.Illustrates the direct effect on an individual left-handed hitter.
Kyle SchwarberBABIP of .240 in 2022.BABIP of .301 in 2024 — a roughly 25% gain.Further supports the observed trend for left-handed batters.

Strategic Rationale Behind the Rule Change

Why did MLB act? The league's stated goal, per its own rule glossary, was about positioning boundaries, but the underlying aim was restoring a balance between offense and defense. The Sports Analytics Group at Berkeley frames it plainly: left-handed hitters found themselves frequently targeted by shifts, and many balls that would have otherwise been hits turned into outs. The 2023 rule change, aiming to restore that balance, was MLB's response.

The infielder side-switching restriction was specifically designed, as the Berkeley group explains, to give hitters more freedom to hit ground balls without worrying about an imbalanced defense. Notably, the vote was not unanimous. ESPN reported that the Competition Committee — six ownership-level representatives, four players and one umpire — saw the player representatives vote no on the shift and pitch-clock portions of the changes.

What teams do now is a matter of working within the box. Two infielders on each side of second base is the floor, not a prescription for where they stand. The remaining tactic is shading — nudging a shortstop or second baseman toward the hole, or toward the bag, based on the same spray-chart data that powered the old shift. The numbers still matter; they just have less room to run.

Measurable Impact on Hitters: A Data-Driven Analysis

Here's where the rules meet the scoreboard. The Berkeley Sports Analytics Group profiled five of the most frequently shifted hitters from 2022 and compared their BABIP — Batting Average on Balls in Play — in 2022 (with shifts) versus 2024 (without shifts). The result: all five left-handed batters experienced BABIP increases.

Two stand out. Corey Seager's BABIP rose from .242 in 2022 to .291 in 2024, a nearly 20% increase. Kyle Schwarber's jumped from .240 to .301, a gain the Berkeley group calls a "whopping 25%." These were exactly the hitters the shift was built to stop — left-handed power bats who pull the ball on the ground — and they're the ones reclaiming hits.

A caveat worth keeping in mind: BABIP moves for many reasons, and a two-season comparison for five players is a correlation, not a controlled experiment. But the direction is consistent across every hitter profiled, and it aligns with what the rule was designed to do — leave more field open for balls in play to find holes.

Penalties for Defensive Shift Violations

What happens if a team breaks the rule? Under the original penalty structure, if an infielder was caught violating the positioning requirements, the batting team had two options: accept the result of the play, or have the hitter be awarded an automatic ball added to the count. That structure gave the offense the choice, which mattered most in counts where an extra ball meant a walk or a better pitch to hit.

Going into the 2025 season, MLB made what its glossary calls a minor tweak to the penalty incurred for violations. The glossary entry outlines the prior two-option structure as the baseline; the specific contours of the 2025 adjustment aren't detailed in the material I'm drawing on here, so I won't guess at them. The practical upshot for readers: the positioning requirements themselves — four infielders on the dirt, two per side, no switching — remain the operative law of the infield, and violations still carry a count-based consequence for the defense.

Navigating the New Defensive Landscape

Teams must strategically adapt their infield positioning within the 2023 rule constraints to optimize defense, while hitters continue to benefit from more open field space and potentially higher BABIPs. That's the deal as it stands: defense gets shading, not stacking; left-handed hitters get the right side of the infield back.

The measurable indicator going forward is continued monitoring of left-handed hitter BABIP trends and team defensive alignment patterns in future MLB seasons. If Seager- and Schwarber-style gains persist, the rule did what it was designed to do. Watch those two numbers — lefty BABIP league-wide and how far infielders shade toward the hole — and you'll see exactly where the modern shift's boundaries sit.

Sources